Mattress Cover Ratings
Summary: We have rated the various bed bug mattress covers available and describe them in detail. Take a look at this article for the facts on getting the best bargain for your money for mattress covers.
Many of you read my first article on bed bug mattress covers describing the different types available for purchase. I thought it necessary to write another article comparing the products to better give you get an idea of what you are buying before you go maxing out your credit card. Remember! We are interested in bed bug control, but not at the cost of sleepless, uncomfortable nights. Let's start at the bottom and work our way up the list beginning with vinyl mattress covers.
The heavy-duty six gauge vinyl mattress cover is priced around $16.
![]() |
Compared to thinner vinyl covers, this six-gauger is proven to tear less. It lasts at least a year under normal conditions and is ideal for use in cribs or on toddlers' beds. It is a nice bargain, but the compromise is that you will be sleeping on vinyl fabric which may not always be the most comfortable. This cover gets a rating of a 2.
The cotton-polyester blend mattress cover, priced at about $64, is a mix of two materials. The cotton material is great for comfort, but still less expensive than 100% cotton mattress covers. Some versions may also be waterproof, which is an added bonus if your plumbing breaks in the middle of the night. We rate this bed bug mattress cover as good, not great. On hot nights you know you are sleeping on polyester. It gets a 4.
Breathable, 100% white terry cotton bed bug mattress covers will run you about $90. This fabric is the industry standard against bed bugs. Hotels tend to buy this kind of cover most often. One brand, called the AllerZip, carried by Fantasy Futons, states that it is 100% proven to trap any bed bugs you may have. The theory is that you can put the mattress cover over your bed bug-infested mattress and the bugs will be unable to escape. They will eventually die and you will not have to worry about the pesky critters again. However, if you get a new infestation of bugs after you have encased your bed, you are back to square one. The advantages to this type of cover are comfort and it also helps keep out dust mites which are allergens for some people. This cover is also less bulky and will sufficiently cool you down in the warm summer months. This is the best bet for anyone who has a severe bed bug infestation, but does not want to shell out the big bucks for a top-of-the-line product. The 100% cotton mattress cover is the most ideal for the average customer with a bed bug infestation. We give it a rating of 8.
The soft and supple micro-weave 100% polyester fabric bed bug mattress cover costs around $95. One brand, called the Pristine Luxury mattress cover, is proven to not only protect against bed bugs, but does a great job against allergens, as well. It has very small pore sizes and is the best choice for someone with many allergies who also happens to have a bed bug infestation. Because it is not quite as heavenly-soft as the 100% cotton mattress cover, we give it a 7.
BugLock encasements, manufactured by Protect-A-Bed of Chicago, are specifically designed for bed bugs. According to the manufacturer, these were the first encasements to be backed by scientific data, proving their effectiveness against bed bugs.
Finally, we get to the ultimate in bed bug mattress covers, the Peruvian organic cotton cover, priced at about $230. This is the epitome of protection against bed bugs that provides the most luxury. The Nahanni 1000 Flannel Pad from Obasan eliminates the threat of bed bugs while ensuring a peaceful night of sleep. It also helps to absorb body moisture. An organic mattress cover is ideal for people who wish to be environmentally friendly. Because this is the most comfortable bed bug mattress cover, we give it a rating of 10. However, if you purchase this kind, don't be surprised when your wallet is thinner.
Comments
31 Mar 2009, 04:30
I moved to a new apartment about 9 months later. After a few months I removed the plastic mattress cover frmo the original infestation thinking all was well. About a month later I found several (less than a dozen) full sized bed bugs on my new solid wood bedframe (in crevaces, corners, screw holes etc). I killed every visible bug and sprayed down the unfinished woodframe with a 50% bleach solution (a bit much, I know but I am crazy about these god forsaken insects). I do a check every night before bed, wake up mid-sleep to do another check and then again in the morning. Needless to say I don't sleep properly.
Here is the thing. I finally learned waht a bedbug egg looks like and have been using tape to remove them and seal them (roll the tape on, pick up the egg,fold it back on itself). I had a few days between killing all the adults that I had no bug findings in my bed. now the past few nights I have been finding 6-10 baby bed bugs (some very, very tiny) every night - always on the bedframe or in my bed mid-sleep. I have intermittant wraps of double sided tape around various parts of the frame and around each of the bed legs - so I know they arent coming from anywhere but the bed frame. Do you think that the baby bugs I am finding now are jsut the residual eggs from the first infestation I noticed? Is it safe to assume that if I keep killing the baby bed bugs that eventualy I will control the infestation (since I am not finding any more adults since the first find/kill)? Should I just throw in the towel and have my landlord get pest control on scene (I don't think its THAT serious yet as we have scoured my roomated room and have found zero signs of bedbugs there). Please give me some advice... how long before I will stop finding the babies if I just keep finding / killing them?
Also, I dusted every crack and crevace of my solid wood bed frame with dichotus (spelling) earth dust... and noticed one time that there was a baby bed bug actually living amongst the dusting (when I picked it up with tape, it was still moving). Did i do this wrong?
31 Mar 2009, 09:49
Bedframes should be disassembled and thoroughly inspected. A lot of work, but worth the effort. Be sure to check every screw hole, too. Failure to inspect every inch will result in further infestation.
Diatomaceous earth would not be my product of choice. Rather, purchase some cans of Bedlam. The pros use it because it has a residual. If you cannot find Bedlam at the hardware store you can find it for sale on-line.
Bleach will kill on contact, but it is not an insecticide. Plus, it can ruin your furniture and fabrics. I prefer using a product by Ginesis. It's an enzyme product and it kills bed bugs on contact.
Keep up the good fight. I think you are winning.
31 Mar 2009, 10:32
Also, I noticed my cat scratching more than usual - she is an indoor cat and we have hardwood floors - so fleas are unlikely. Can she be bitten by the bedbugs as well since she sleeps on my bed?
31 Mar 2009, 14:50
Bed bugs favor human blood, but "any port in a storm" will do. That includes cats.
17 Jul 2009, 17:42
18 Jul 2009, 07:26
Regardless of what you use, finding every bed bug and bed bug egg is essential and will require much close-up work. I suggest using a magnifying glass to help.
The couch is a problem. Bed bugs get way down into the folds of the upholstry. Over-treating with pesticides could ruin the couch. Some companies offer a heat treatment in a portable container. They can treat just your couch or other specific items, without having to treat the entire apartment, which is costly. Call around for that service if you want to save your couch.
24 Jul 2009, 22:41
27 Jul 2009, 10:01
09 Aug 2009, 13:48
We picked up some hitchhiking bedbugs at a hotel and brought em back to our apartment.
We read online and buy a vapor cleaner. Lots of hours and bagging later, we decided to just toss our bedframes, mattresses, and some other furniture. Then we moved.
At the new place, we brought in no furniture from the old place. Only sealed bagged washed items. We brought in a mattress and some furniture from our old house (tied up in litigation) that has no pest problems and has been uninhabited for over a year.
We sleep on the floor, but start getting bit again. We bring our baby in to the pediatrician, and he says these are flea bites - probably from the last tenant. He says it is safe to bomb the house if you stay out a few hours past when the can says.
We wash everything and vaporclean the hell out of that room.
To be safe, we call in a bedbug seeking K-9.
The dog IDs 3 spots for bedbugs. I don't get it. The dog did not ID anything in the structure. She ID'd the mattress we brought over, which was encased the 3rd day we had it here. She ID'd a sealed bag of washed laundry (washed in scalding hot water) and she ID'd a piece of furniture that was next to the mattress she ID'd - but had been vapored before bringing it in.
No spots on carpet, wallboards etc.
How could she ID the garbage bag of laundry that had been hot washed? It was 1 bag in a big pile of other bags.
I hope we are near the end of our trials. This has taken a ton of effort and I have been afraid to use pesticides due to the kids, so I have been painstakingly vaporing everything or what cannot be putting it in the deepfreeze for 10 days.
Do the dogs hit or miss that much? Could she be correct - nothing on the carpet but with the mattress, bedstand, and bag of laundry? Her handler could find no evidence of them at all and advised us not to spray and just forget about them.
24 Aug 2009, 14:19
01 Sep 2009, 01:58
We went to the camp and brought some unexpected bedbugs back. Found where the infestation was-vacuumed the mattress, frames, cleaned mattress with lysol wipes also used a magical chinese chock for insecticide all over the bedframe, floors.
What type of zipped mattress cover u also recommend the most.
Thank you.

